Here's my take: In: Henderson--The greatest of all time (his words, not mine, but I almost agree). The guy had speed and power, played a decent outfield. Revolutionized the idea of a "leadoff" guy, immediate impact on every game he played. Not to mention, the speech would be must see TV. Blyleven--absolutely ridiculous this guy isn't in. If he played in NY or Boston he'd have been in on the first or second ballot Tommy John--I know wins are overrated, but my God, the guy got that many after the surgery that bears his name. If he never gets in, they at least need to put him in for "contributors to the game" or something. Frankly, he probably deserves both. McGwire--I know he roided up, but so did nearly everyone else in the 1990s. Also, had some damn good years in the late 80s/early 90s when he wasn't very big. One dimensional, but a legendary 1 dimension. Raines--If not for Rickey, he'd be the pre-eminent leadoff man of the modern era. SB% is nuts. Again, playing in small market most of the time will hurt him. 2nd Tier Guys (Don't really deserve it, but wouldn't be a travesty): Dawson--Turf in Montreal cost him the Hall of Fame. Sad stuff. One of the heroes of my youth. Would have 600 HRs if he was on roids. Trammell--Solid, but unspectacular. Playing SS helps, but offense wasn't quite good enough. Smith--Good closer, but neither revolutionary (Gossage/Sutter) or dominant enough (Rivera) and didn't compile enough saves (Hoffman) 3rd Tier Guys (At least have a case with a few people): Jack Morris--Greatest postseason pitcher I've ever seen. Unbelievable mustache. Murphy--Multiple MVPs on bad teams, but not a long enough peak. Killed his body in CF. Grace--Hits are nice, but in era of power, he was easily replaceable. Baines--Longevity nice, but didn't hang on long enough for 3,000 hits Rice--Good player with nice, but short, peak. If he was on KC or Seattle, would have been an afterthought.