This quandry can really be traced back to AGon. Remember, in 2003, AGon and Damien Miller were like a black hole at the bottom of the order, especially factoring in the pitcher spot. Miller, in particular, really struggled offensively, falling well below his career norms. Luckily, even though AGon also fell below career norms, he played out of his head in the playoffs. Come 2004, the Cubs concluded it was easier to rid themselves of Miller than AGon's salary. This, in large part, is indicative of the Cubs' problem. Nevermind that the premier SS in the league was available that offseason, the Cubs could not swallow sitting AGon at the salary he was making. Instead, Hendry chased after one of his long coveted players, Michael Barrett. All of the pitchers seemed to enjoy throwing to Miller. And, in fact, they excelled under his watch. I don't know if there is a correlation for sure, but you have to wonder.