Was that the all time single season tackle record, or career? If it's career, it doesn't say a thing about being fully recovered. And leading the team in tackles doesn't either. Your linebackers will always lead the team in tackles. If you play most of the season at LB, you stand a great chance of leading the team in tackles. Neither of those stats proves a guy is fully recovered. career. But his season totals were: 116 tackles 69 solo 10 TFL 3 sacks That's as MLB Last year (when "healthy") he was an OLB and posted 118 tackles 64 solo 14 TFL 4 sacks In 2005, he was the first junior team captain for PSU since 1968 2005 All-American, Butkus and Bednarik Award Winner 2006 All-American and Bednarkik Award Winner (2nd ever to win twice) So yeah, that's him. Yeah, I know who he is, but none of that says he's fully recovered. MLB rack up the most tackles simply by their position, most of the time. I'm not sure anybody is saying he was bad, just not as good as they were hoping/expecting. A great player can lose a step and still dominate the level he's already dominated, in this case, college. But if you've lost something, people will rightfully increase their doubts about your ability to dominate the next level. Besides, just because he's not in the top 25 doesn't mean he's not regarded highly. He could be 26 on the list. Or he could be 40, that's still somebody you would expect to make an impact in his rookie year, in other words, somebody Mel would still respect highly as a football player.