It's not one game. It's really just about every game. You know that NLCS and WS MVP David Freese guy that hit the walkoff HR and game tying triple in game 6? If the Cards had even a 1 run lead in the 8th, he's not playing because of defense. Think I'm exaggerating? He started 19 games in September and finished 4. He finished 7 of 18 postseason games. Obviously he's just a butcher defender to be pulled like that right? His UZR and DRS are both better than the guy who was replacing him in the 7th,8th and 9th in 2/3 of games. Goofy bullpen management non stop, anyone can play 2nd base, allowing Corey Patterson to play baseball on his team, etc. The postseason was Tony at his absolute best, and nearly all of his moves were just common sense moves. And even then he had to fail the first time before getting the point. Here's a good link for you... http://www.gatewayredbirds.com/forum/viewtopic.php?f=1&t=35375 The key to his success over the last decade has been having arguably the best 1b to play the game being underpaid and an ownership group willing to spend for elite talent, Rolen, Edmonds, Walker, Holliday, Berkman etc.