I cut them down to show you the painfully obvious; it's your problem, not mine, that you don't understand BAbip and LD% and the like to see that he was actually performing (and how his numbers in April were skewed) along the lines of what was hoped until the wrist sidelined him. Of course players are going to go hot and cold, and we only have a little sample size with which to judge Stewart this year, but you're acting like his good numbers are flukishly good as opposed to being what should be expected. Based on the numbers, yes, it appeared that he had a decent shot of getting back to his 2009-2010 production until he had to be shut down. You're trying to present any success he had as an anomaly when those numbers are actually more in line with his career numbers than being representative of some kind of anomalous hot streak. Unless you're saying you think the 182 PA from 2011 and 2007 are more indicative of his line than the 1236 PA between 2008 and 2010.