I agree that the contract being talked about is awful...but is everyone that willing to overlook the 2 good years prior to last year that Marquis put up?? I know this may sound crazy...but Marquis has a 4.55 career ERA. Lilly's is 4.60. We gave Lilly 4/40... 15-7, 3.71, 201.1 IP 13-14, 4.13, 207 IP 14-16, 6.02, 194.1 IP 12-10, 4.06, 197.1 IP 10-11, 5.56, 126.1 IP 15-13, 4.31, 181.2 IP Other than the timing of their down years, which pitcher would you rather have??