He also traded James McDonald+ for Dotel, and Josh Bell+ For George Sherrill(Bell turned into nothing, but he was a top prospect 2 months later, and he got a terrible return for him because he's dumb) The Dotel trade was awful. I would have preferred getting McDonald and Andrew Lambo for Lilly and Theriot and I'm confident that those guys,had to be on the table, because they were more valuable than Dotel obviously. That said, McDonald needed a change of scenery. They gave him chances out there and he wasn't getting it done. Don't get me wrong, they should have gotten much more than they did, but he had lost quite a bit of luster. Lambo was the guy everyone was shocked about being included, because he had been a top 100 guy just a season before, if I remember correctly. But had 2 strikes on the drug policy already. I hate defending Ned, by the way, because I don't consider him a good GM. But he's done OK with what he's been given. Some good trades, a couple bad ones, and a spotty FA record. Below average? Yes. But not bad enough to run your franchise into the ground.