Too scary for me. Lots of money, injury concerns, and high acquisition cost. I'd take any of the others(Archer, Gray, Fernandez, Corbin, Teheran) over him once all things are considered. Edit- Cashman doesn't seem the type to package guys together either. But who knows? I don't think he's ever sold before. I'd love to add Miller. In fact, I voted for a reliever if we could only add one piece. At any rate, all things considered, I'd take plenty of others over Tanaka. Not necessarily from a talent standpoint, but weighing it all out, I think there's better options for us. What's the trade cost for a Tanaka compared to those other guys? That's a rough one - if you're scared to pay up for Tanaka then you should probably be crapping your pants at the cost for a Fernandez or really any of those guys. Heck, what's his injury risk compared to the others? Two of the guys listed have already had TJ surgery and Archer's probably a bigger injury risk today than Tanaka is. I figure the extra years of control would heighten the cost on Tanaka. Of course, his salary would bring it back down somewhat. Hamels maybe a comp? He's not as good as him and has some injury history, but maybe a package like that, minus one top 100 guy? I'd prefer a guy coming off TJS than a guy who's avoided it, albeit with concerns. Plus, my true guess is the Yankees won't trade him anyway. They're not going to rebuild and with Strasburg off the market, they've got no options to replace him. Not since they can't really compete with some other teams in the trade market.