i guess that involves speculating as to what available funds the FO has to work with but another way of looking at it, is would you rather give up a decent piece for Maybin and his 3/20 commitments, or take a chance on Chris B. Young for just money? fWAR, last 4 years Young (age 29): 2010 - 4.1 2011 - 4.5 2012 - 2.5 (363 PA) 2013 - 0.5 (375 PA) Maybin (age 26): 2010 - 0.5 (322 PA) 2011 - 4.2 2012 - 2.3 2013 - N/A, inj. sure, you have to like Maybin being nearer to his prime, but FG crowdsource believes Young will get 2Y/$13.6M which seems like it could be a better allocation of resources but what the hell, get both and trade Schierholtz; Sweeney & Bogusevic aren't the worst contingencies