Dewan ranked him 32nd out of 35 CF's. Not too good. What kind of defensive ranking has Jim Edmonds ranked as nearly the worst defensive centerfielder in the game? I hate Edmonds, but it's pretty silly (IMO) to say that he doesn't have a good glove. John Dewan's Fielding Bible is considered pretty authoritative. Michael is the person to ask if you want an explanation for why Edmonds is ranked too low. Michael did an interview with Dewan. FWIW, other metrics (PMR, UZR, Davenport, BBTF's zone rating) rank Edmonds from pretty average to pretty good, but not superior. I love you man. Yes, I think Edmonds is very overrated in terms of defense. His range most likely wasn't great in his prime and I think stinks now. That said, he has a very, very good arm. Link