Sure I can. You can, but that's how the Cardinals end up with Shelby Miller at pick 19. Miller was the 13th pitcher taken in that draft, and the 7th HS pitcher. To be clear, I'm being a bit facetious with the "not ever" bit, but Goony's hypothetical happens very rarely if you're constricting yourself to the Top 10 picks. Beyond that and you have to start considering guys with superior talent who've fallen for other reasons, pitcher or not. "Don't take a pitcher in the Top 10" is not the same as "Don't draft Shelby Miller at 19" I didn't look at specifics of his draft, but I wasn't saying don't draft Shelby Miller at 19. I was saying that if Kyle sticks to his guns, that's how you end up with a guy as talented as Miller clearly is falling to 19. Now, that must have been a very deep draft pitching wise for him to fall that far. Fake edit: Looking at it, and not being a guy who follows the minors really closely, I recognize all but 3 of the guys taken ahead of him. Many of those have had some significant success already, so that was definitely not the best example to use.