NSBB.com or the Platte River Valley? I think some do overrated his defense, but it's much better than Pierre's and very good. I agree that he's better than Pierre, but I'm not sure about "very good." His range has always been spectacular. Defensive metrics that measure range (and nothing else) place him among the best CFers in baseball. Other metrics that take other factors into account, like Davenport's, for example, rank him as below average over his career. But I would never have traded Patterson for Pierre straight up. Instead, Hendry gave away Patterson for what will probably amount to nothing while giving up three pitchers for Pierre. I still can't believe we're paying Pierre more than we would have had to pay Patterson to be a worse player, and we had to give up several good prospects for the privilege to do so.