no i don't believe all players produce equally during clutch situations. i think better hitters produce better in clutch situations than worse hitters. i don't think arod is worse than average in clutch situations. i think every time he does fail (appx 65-70% of the time) it gets way overblown, and when he does succeed, it tends to be forgotten. for what it's worth, here's arod's "clutch" splits. they're pretty close to what his career numbers are, which i think tends to be the case for most players. Ok, that's fair enough. I'm assuming your chart consists of ARod's entire career. What's his Yankee-only stats? Playoff stats? I think that's relevant since he didn't receive the "unclutch" tag until playing for the Yankees. Late and Close is the only category I'd really consider "clutch," but I also think 2 Outs, Men in scoring position stats have "clutch" merit. Coincidentally, ARod hits noticeably worse in both situations than in his career average.