It only makes sense to let the team in that has sucked for a month and is missing key components to injuries as opposed to the one that has been hot. If the decision was based on their "rivalry," then Manuel really is an idiot. Oh, come on. If a team can keep a division rival out that's what they're going to play for. "Hot" teams stumble all the time in the playoffs, just like everyone else, so it's ridiculous to expect teams to act like the people here who just assume the Cardinals always win. The Braves made the playoffs 15 years in a row and won 1 title. For that reason alone I would have rather had them in than the Cardinals were I the Phillies. The Braves find ways to choke every year. So the logic behind this is you think the Phillies should have gone, "hey, division rivals, we're going to let you in because you've been bad the last month and the Cardinals have been good, nevermind in the short series "hot" teams get the boot all the damn time. Plus they're the Cardinals and EVERYTHING goes their way because of magic or unholy luck or whatever and, because, y'know"? I would have tried to keep the best offense in the NL out and the best player in baseball.