AHAHAAh 2004 A: .292/.352/.471, 114 OPS+, .280 EqA B: .286/.375/.512, 131 OPS+, .300 Eqa 2005 A: .309/.389/.450, 125, .293 B: .321/.421/.610, 173, .338 2006 A: .343/.417/.483, 132, .307 B: .290/.392/.523, 134, .301 2007 A: .322/.388/.452, 121, .285 B: .314/.422/.645, 177, .339 Going to go with player B in all of those years. 2006 is close though.