After their first 8 full seasons: Gehrig: .345/.448/.644, 186 OPS+, 1610 Hits, 278 HR, 334 Doubles, 114 Triples, 1203 RBI, 1132 Runs, 849 Walks Pujols: .334/.425/.624, 170 OPS+, 1531 Hits, 319 HR, 342 Doubles, 13 Triples, 977 RBI, 947 Runs, 696 Walks Pujols is likely to retire as the second greatest first baseman of all time, perhaps even the first.