Found it sorta interesting while rabbit-trailing on BR today that Bagwell was only a four time all-star. Seems like he would have made more than that. Looking through the NL rosters of the years when he was in his prime but didn't make it, it looks like he suffered multiple times from the "every team must have a player" rule because twice Richie Sexson and twice Sean Casey made all-star teams when Bags didn't. Same with Ryan Klesko in 2001 with the Padres. Helton was on a bunch of the teams too that Bags wasn't on and was the only player from the Rockies a few of those years, although I think he may have gotten in on merit those years anyways. You could also automatically subtract a spot for Bags during most of his career because of McGwire and then Pujols.