Umpire discretion. It's like a ball hit down the line that's called foul but on replay it hit the line. The umps determine where they beleive the runner would have ended up. Umpire discretion via replay was literally added with the advent of replay. The default has always been when play is ruled dead, anything that was potentially in progress is dead, regardless of intent, spirit, etc. Exactly. And to the foul ball analogy, if the umpire had called a foul and blown it dead incorrectly, it doesn't matter if the batter ran for a triple. It's a strike at that point. No Ok, ok, I went too far with that one. :blush: