No offense but I think Rodgers and Rivers might be ahead of Brees now. Admittedly, Brees could easily bounce back next season. I can agree with that. Wouldn't you put Brady ahead of Manning at this point? Manning struggled a bit during the season at times. Yes, he had no help, but Brady seemed to be at his peak even though his receiving options are also less than elite. I'd go: Brady Manning Rodgers Brees Rivers That would be my list too. I don't see how Brady isn't number one.