yes, you can totally know this after a whopping 150 big league plate appearances :roll: Well people already know that Gerut is gonna be a worse ML player than Dubois by the end of their career so why can't I know the opposite? Because it's different than how you feel? it's okay, dude - being a hypocrite is all right with me! I'm not judging the deal, I never did in my post. Learn what hypocracy means before you use it. I believe Dubois is AAAA player based on what I've seen. I have no idea what Gerut will be. What you quoted was me playing devils advocate. I have no idea whether gerut will be worse or better than Dubois. well, i certainly don't know what "hypocracy" is, but i do know what "hypocrisy" is. you are judging the trade, or it certainly appears so, by 1. calling dubois an AAAA player (when he hasn't even had over 200 PAs in the bigs, i believe it was 152 this year) and 2. attacking those who believe the deal isn't a good move while i agree that no strong opinions should be made about the deal until we see how each player does on their new team, my first impression is that this is a lateral move at best, and i don't see what the problem is with having an opinion at first. Do we have to rehash the 30+ page thread again in this one?