You honestly believe that even with the fact that Maddux's ERA, though rising the past few years, is still better than those two guys? And the fact that's he's well on his way to another 15+ win season while those two can't put back to back good starts together? You'd honestly feel more comfortable in our chances of winning with them on the mound than Greg Maddux? I don't even know why I'm still in this discussion. It's bordering on insanity. Yes, I do feel more comfortable with those 2, because they aren't going to be much worse(if not better) than Maddux, while we have 9 million more to improve elsewhere. That's the difference between a J.D. Drew, and a Danny Bautista, to pull 2 names out of thin air. JD Drew is being paid MORE than Maddux to underproduce. Are you sure you don't want to rethink that? The point is, do you want Maddux and Denny Bautista, or Mitre/Hill/Williams and Drew? Considering we can have both, I'm not sure what the point of this question is. Hahah, really? Because I see Dubois and Hollandsworth sucking it up right now. Next year, 9 million dollars is going to go into Maddux's pocket. That is likely to be around 1/10th of our payroll. Are you ok with spending 1/10th of our payroll on a 4+ ERA, when we could get the same thing for 900k from the trio of kids? I'm not. Why not? At least he plays. No one seems to be angry about paying 1/5 of our payroll for 2 guys who don't even play (one not even on the team and the other on the DL for 2/3rds of every season). You're angry about Dubois? Which side of this argument are you on? You'd rather bring in an expensive underachiever rather then let Dubois play for much cheaper and give him a chance to devlop into a equal player? If you think Maddux is the reason we didn't sign JD Drew, I don't even know what to say to you. I think it's hilarious that people think Maddux is some sort of cash sucking albatross that is easily replaced by unproven rookies and keeping us from signing a LFer. I don't see why we would take away something that isn't a problem because he is mythically keeping us from signing left fielders.