I agree. I get tired of reading posts with these Moneyball stats being the only way to evaluate a player. Sure OPS is a useful stat, but I refuse to believe that any one stat can truly reflect someone's value. No single stat can tell you everything about a player, but the argument that a player is good simply because he has a decent OBP false. That is a very important part of the game, but not the only one. What the argument over Theriot was doing was exactly what you say you dislike, focusing on one stat to tell the whole story for a player, OBP, while ignoring SLG. Add them together, and you get a stat that doesn't tell you everything about a player, but gives you a vital overview of their offensive contribution that correlates very well with runs scored.