Um, sure, if you're simply looking at Wins: Zambrano - 28-13 Maddux - 27-22 Prior - 16-9 Wood - 11-13 But he has the worst two-year ERA of the four, the lowest K/9IP, and this year, the worst WHIP. He also leads the 2005 Cubs in losses, HR allowed, Hits allowed, lowest Pitches/Start, and earned runs. The counting stats will be partly a function of innings pitched. I don't doubt hits allowed; I'll note that Prior, Williams and Wood have higher HR/9 rates (didn't bother with Wood's splits; he hasn't been healthy this year, anyway). None of them are good HR/9 rates. I always figured Maddux would vest. He was a far better bet than Wood vesting his '07 option.