You have to be careful to distinguish between proclamations made here and what's been said by the team. Folks around here have a tendency to assume the worst, and many people here openly believe Miles will eventually be the starter (based on nothing more than gut). Belief in cyber-reality is stated as fact (as I just did - that irony isn't lost). Then it gets repeated in a few dozen threads. But the organization hasn't said much other than to say that Fontenot has earned the opportunity to win the job everyday based on his play last year. I've seen quotes to the effect that Miles will be tried at 3B, SS, 2B, and the OF this spring. Bottom line is Lou doesn't hand many non-fully established players an everyday job outright. He believes in the power of positive competition between teammates and sometimes his expectations carry a short-leash for results. We won't really know Miles' role until May or June probably. That's a pretty broad characterization of the board, and it's probably not necessary. Anyone and everyone can make their own conclusion of how the 2nd base job will be determined. Fontenot has very little major league experience hitting lefties. It's a pretty safe assumption that Fontenot's bat will be in the line up against RHP, since management has expressed a need for lefty bats in the line up. However, when a LHP is on the mound, it's another safe assumption that Miles will get the call, since Lou likes to go with a RH dominant line up against LHP. While this would indicate a platoon, Fontenot will be the main benefactor of playing time since there are way more RHP's than LHP's. In a sense, you can call it a platoon. Lou does like his veterans. If Fontenot steps up early, then the risk of losing playing time to Miles (who can hit from both sides of the plate, though not very well) will be lessened.