I really love McCann, but as the time grows near I'll have to evaluate which pool is deeper, MI or catcher. I'll probably be selecting around the 6th pick or so, so theres a decent chance I could draft whoever I don't pick. I have to imagine the difference between Phillips and the other 2Bs will be greater than the difference between McCann and the other available catchers. So even if you keep Phillips and don't get McCann in the draft, it won't be terrible. I'm just always skeptical about putting too much stock in catchers. They are almost always easily replaceable. Yeah, looking at catchers this year it seems like a pretty darn deep position this year in a 12 team 1 catcher league. This year it isn't just the M's (Mauer, McCann, Martinez, and Martin) and a bunch of slop. With Soto, Wieters, Doumit, Napoli, and Iannetta there are a lot of other options out there to not have to waste a keeper on. Even ending up with Posada, Clement, or Molina wouldn't be the end of the world and there you go, thats 13 catchers in a 12 catcher league. Its looking to me that beyond the 5th round (since our first 5 rounds are keeper) that 1b and 3B are pretty shallow. At 1B I'm guessing Pujols, Miggy, Howard, Berkman, Tex, Morneau, Fielder, Adrian Gonz, and Youk will be kept. Leaving DLee, Chris Davis, Carlos Pena, and Votto as reasonable alternatives (and since we play with a CI, teams are going to end up with 2-3 1Bs). At 3B ARod, Wright, Longoria, ARam, and Chipper will be kept. But after that theres not a lot of greatness. Theres Atkins and Figgins and then a whole lotta meh.