A half season's worth of number be damned, I take Beltran over McLouth and Zambrano over...scratch that, Lincecum is better than Z... but anyways, if winning the game is important then you take players who are still in their prime and have a longer history of better production. I do disagree with how Perry wrote the captions, using past all star appearances as reasons that they should make the team this year, but I don't have much of a problem with most of his choices.