Beckman is a fine recruiter. Illinois is recruiting more or less at the level of Wisconsin and Iowa right now. They are in the mix in that second tier of BT teams. Only sustained success can take them higher than that. But the state produces a lot of surplus talent in the form of 3 - star kids that could make the jump. They will have to get there with those types. Beckman may not be the one to do it, but Beckman doesn't do much anyway. Last year, they had the worst recruiting class in the big ten. '13 was decent at 47, 15' is looking better at around 50. You need an elite recruiter who can recruit nationally or at least regionally. You get too spastic about state lines. Being the top recruiter in Illinois isn't going to get them where they need to be. Schools like Illinois should not recruit nationally. It's a waste of recruiting effort. They should recruit regionally on the states below, w/ a focus on IL. IL -#9 state for producing d1 football players OH -#5 MI -#10 MO PA #8 There is more then enough talent to go around there. I think that's UI's strategy, too, though looking at the rankings, it doesn't seem like they get as many good players as they should. The big keys are scheme, identifying talent, and development, imo. KSU has 32 guys on the two-deep that are walkons or JUCOs. They can get to the top 10 that way because they have a scheme that they've perfected, they identify guys who will fit into that scheme (many of them lightly recruited for being a little slow or a little short), and they have amazing player development. I don't know enough about Beckman/his staff to know if they're talented in those areas.