Hill has allowed the same amount of HR's as Lilly, even though Lilly has pitched 14 2/3 innings more. So Hill has given up a greater HR/9 than Lilly, not less. Their K/BB ratio is close, but Lilly's is a little better (3.06 for Lilly to 2.88 for Hill). Lilly's WHIP is better-1.150 to 1.219. They've been close this year, but Lilly has been slightly better in every phase of the game besides straight K rate. I must have transposed the numbers. Ok, you've convined me. I'll go with Lilly. If I knew I was going to get the "good Z", the choice would be easy, but he's been about as predictible as Cybil.