Hmmm, well JAWS has him as the 16th ranked RF ever. The other guys on your list according to JAWS Ruth #1 RF Mays #1 CF Williams #2 LF Bonds #1 LF I mean, if he had played in the MLB starting at age 21 or something, then he might have ended up 5th or so in RF all time, but as it stands now he’s not an Inner Circle HOF like those other guys. To me, he's as close to Ty Cobb as we are ever going to see in our lifetime. I think if he would have played his entire career here, he'd be right up there and probably would have broken Rose's hit record.