Probably. Could you be more specific? well, anyone who has seen the first month of the year could tell you that pie doesn't have the ability to put up a .900 OPS against major league RHP at this stage of his career; he needs better discipline and pitch recognition skills for that to happen. and, as i said a page back, PECOTA doesn't have the ability to determine when a guy is going to age well, or fall off a cliff in terms of production. edmonds EqA trend the past 4 years: 2004: .341 2005: .307 2006: .285 2007: .260 now the PECOTA projections are .263 and .271 in 2008 and 2009, respectively. how am i supposed to take those seriously when he's been shaving anywhere from 22 to 35 points off his EqA in the past few years? in my opinion, PECOTA really can't tell us anything about jim edmonds. he's well past his prime, he can't run well, his bat is much slower, he doesn't have much power any more.