Not saying Dale Murphy should get in because I don't think he should. I don't think he had the longevity that most voters want. He did have a hell of a peak though. Murphy had a six year peak where he averaged .289/.382/.531/.913, 145 OPS+, 36 HR, 105 RBI, 110 runs, 18 SB, and won 5 gold gloves. My guess is that in 1984ish Future Hall of Famer was often used when talking about Dale Murphy. If I remember correctly he went from really great to really bad in 2 seasons. As for the trivia I know the player who played for the winning Pirates and one of the overall #1s who didn't make it to the majors. I looked it up and would have never gotten the other guy yeah i don't think anyone who isn't 80 years old with an encyclopedic knowledge of baseball history would get that one. matt bush may actually avoid becoming #3 on that list - he had a solid year in relief with the rays, struck out a lot of batters and was added to their 40 man roster. he's very unlikely to be a star, but there's a decent chance that he gets a cup of coffee.