I think Carkner went overboard. Something probably needed to be done, but what he did to Boyle was waaaaaaaay worse than that Boyle did to Karlsson in Game 1. Regardless, I will now be adding this to the list of series I am watching closely. Which I think is now all except NJ-FLA and BOS-WSH. Those two just aren't holding my interest. Yet. The problem with this whole letting players clean up the dirty plays is that it will always escalate. Of course any real old timey fan would probably say that Boyle should have dropped his gloves and not turtled. To me that is why I had no problem them giving Dubinsky a 3rd man in game misconduct. Boyle knew it was coming and deserved if NHL players want to play by "the code of whatever" and he turtled. He should have dropped his gloves, grabbed and held on to Carkner's right arm and moved on. To his credit though his actions did get The Rangers a 5 min PP. If fans and players want to keep this code this is what is going to happen. If not then the NHL needed to suspend Boyle for what he did to Karlsson....which way do you want it? You are absolutely right about Boyle. You have to face the music. Though he sort of didn't get a chance under the circumstances. yeah, he DID face the music. someone challenged him to fight later in the period and he fought the guy. it's not "turtling" if someone checks you when the puck isn't around and you're not looking, immediately throws off his gloves and starts wailing on your face. boyle is a tough guy and is willing to fight under a normal circumstance; carkner is (and has always been) a dumbass who went about it the wrong way. come on, newusername.