utility player, utility player, 5th starter, inconsistent guy with #2/3 talent, 5th outfielder, inconsistent pitcher with good arm who's better suited for the bullpen To be fair, Hill's been pretty consistent, all in all, over the past year. Of late, he's been inconsistent, though. And Marmol's been lights out in the 'pen. I don't disagree with your other assessments, however. In fact, you might be a little optimistic with Pagan. as most know, i'm big on hill, but i realize that many folks may not be as high on him as i am. But he certainly can be an above-average starter. Marmol has been lights out, but his history suggests that he may have some control issues. Those two are the most valuable players on that list above, though. Three (Theriot, Fontenot, Pagan) have almost no value at all.