Jump to content
North Side Baseball
Posted

Being a starting pitcher in the majors leagues really is, in a way, like flying. It's an incredible feat of engineering. It can only be sustained for so long, even with the marvels of modern technology. And you need a clear runway to get off the ground. 

Taylor Clarke never had a smooth enough runway to gather speed and lift off. He came close. After being a third-round pick by the Diamondbacks in 2015, Clarke had three full, healthy seasons in the minors, working as a starter the whole time. He never became a top-100 starter on the national landscape or anything, but he progressed to Triple-A and emerged as a legitimate candidate to start for Arizona. In fact, he started 20 games and spent about half of both the 2019 and 2020 seasons in the rotation. Things didn't go terribly well, but those seasons were badly distorted—by the most homer-happy season in league history, and then by a global pandemic.

That was enough, though. Those few bumps slowed Clarke down, just as he needed to gather the last bit of speed and put the wind on the right side of his wing flaps. That's when injuries hit him, like obstacles on the runway. From 2021 through 2024, his campaigns were interrupted or derailed by injuries to his shoulder, oblique, elbow and knee. None of them were exceptionally severe. He underwent Tommy John surgery, but it was way back in college, in 2013. For the most part, Clarke has been an impressively durable arm. However, that lost momentum a half-decade ago (and the fact that was out of options) forced him to the bullpen.

Healthy at last, he thrived there in 2025 and 2026. Clarke has been released three times and traded once, so although he pitched in 2026 with the same team that drafted him 11 years ago, it was after stints in the Kansas City and Milwaukee organizations. He spent all of 2024 in the minors with the Brewers, working mostly as a starter, but that only confirmed for him that his path to a big-league job was working in relief. With the Royals in 2025 and Diamondbacks in 2026, he did just that, and the results have been superb. 

Since the start of 2025, Clarke has pitched in 122 big-league games, all (essentially) in relief. He's compiled 128 1/3 innings, with a 73 ERA-, a 94 FIP- and a 4.7% walk rate. He doesn't miss as many bats as one would prefer, at least in his current form, but he's been very durable and very sturdy.

As a reliever, Clarke throws roughly 95 miles per hour with his sinker. The real story, though, is that he switched from a four-seamer to a cutter in 2026, and he was still able to throw the pitch at 94 MPH. A cutter that firm—especially playing off his tight slider, which averages 88-89 MPH—is a major weapon, and it had much to do with the way Clarke got batters out in his walk year. Having discovered this pitch, he's better equipped to keep the ball in the park and fill up the zone than ever before. 

image.png

Clarke will have a strong enough market this winter to ensure a big-league deal. It's easy to stand out from whatever crowd of teams lines up to bid for him, though: Offer him a chance to start. He'll turn 34 next May; he's not a traditional candidate to move back to the rotation. His stuff is good enough to make that possible, though. Starting again, he might lose a tick on the fastballs, but he's shown good enough feel for his stuff to find ways around whatever problems that raises. He could ratchet the usage of his four-seamer back up, to achieve a true three-fastball mix. His slider and changeup are good offerings. He should be able to get out both left- and right-handed batters. And if the experiment of re-converting doesn't pan out, he could always help in the bullpen.

The Cubs need three starting pitchers well clear of Clarke's level. They also need to reinforce their bullpen. But depth is almost as big a problem as upside for this staff, and Clarke offers a low-cost way to address it. He might even have more upside than meets the eye.

Image courtesy of David Frerker-Imagn Images

View full article

Recommended Posts

Posted

The Cubs left themselves in an incredibly poor position.

After running the numbers, it’s almost unbelievable. The Cubs need five starting pitchers, a left fielder, a right fielder, a second catcher and a DH. As currently constituted, that’s a roster built for a last-place finish. How could a competent management team leave itself in this position?

And the articles I keep seeing suggest the answer is a list of never-were's and might-be's.

But because of baseball’s economic structure, the Cubs can recover. They could sign five veteran starting pitchers projected around a 4.00 ERA, fill their other needs, and have a reasonable expectation of winning about 95 games — roughly 850 runs scored and 700 allowed, just like this year.

The cost: about $300 million in luxury-tax payroll, plus roughly $25 million in penalties. It also takes a willingness to eat those contracts later, when the players get older, get hurt, or stop producing.

It’s all a matter of priority. If management wants to win, it can. If it doesn’t do this, it’s telling you winning isn’t the priority.

Sorry, Cub fans.

Posted
1 hour ago, PVG said:

The Cubs left themselves in an incredibly poor position.

After running the numbers, it’s almost unbelievable. The Cubs need five starting pitchers, a left fielder, a right fielder, a second catcher and a DH. As currently constituted, that’s a roster built for a last-place finish. How could a competent management team leave itself in this position?

And the articles I keep seeing suggest the answer is a list of never-were's and might-be's.

But because of baseball’s economic structure, the Cubs can recover. They could sign five veteran starting pitchers projected around a 4.00 ERA, fill their other needs, and have a reasonable expectation of winning about 95 games — roughly 850 runs scored and 700 allowed, just like this year.

The cost: about $300 million in luxury-tax payroll, plus roughly $25 million in penalties. It also takes a willingness to eat those contracts later, when the players get older, get hurt, or stop producing.

It’s all a matter of priority. If management wants to win, it can. If it doesn’t do this, it’s telling you winning isn’t the priority.

Sorry, Cub fans.

They don't need 5 SP.  They can find at least 2 between Cabrera, Steele, Assad, Garrett, Wicks, Wiggins, and the other assortment of arms currently under contract.  

Posted
1 hour ago, PVG said:

The Cubs left themselves in an incredibly poor position.

After running the numbers, it’s almost unbelievable. The Cubs need five starting pitchers, a left fielder, a right fielder, a second catcher and a DH. As currently constituted, that’s a roster built for a last-place finish. How could a competent management team leave itself in this position?

And the articles I keep seeing suggest the answer is a list of never-were's and might-be's.

But because of baseball’s economic structure, the Cubs can recover. They could sign five veteran starting pitchers projected around a 4.00 ERA, fill their other needs, and have a reasonable expectation of winning about 95 games — roughly 850 runs scored and 700 allowed, just like this year.

The cost: about $300 million in luxury-tax payroll, plus roughly $25 million in penalties. It also takes a willingness to eat those contracts later, when the players get older, get hurt, or stop producing.

It’s all a matter of priority. If management wants to win, it can. If it doesn’t do this, it’s telling you winning isn’t the priority.

Sorry, Cub fans.

I hear you. I agree with @mul21 that you're dooming a little too hard on the rotation, but I also think you've actually undershot what filling their needs via free agency would cost. Think more like $330 million in CBT spend. I would guess they attack it a bit more through trade and with some small FA moves, rather than swinging big on many free-agent pursuits. If you feel that's insufficient, I understand, but I think the solution you propose would be phenomenally difficult logistically (getting that many guys in a competitive marketplace where supply is limited is hard!) and so much more expensive than you're suggesting that it's probably impossible.

Realistically, I don't think there's any way they can project to win 95 games going into next year, and I very much doubt that'll be their goal. Instead, they'll try to rearrange and better balance their roster; spend where they can; and go in with an 87-win projection or something, hoping to outperform that and/or improve along the way, via prospect promotions or the trade deadline. To put it succinctly: I think you're wrong that ownership or the FO could will them back to the top of the heap, even if they wanted to. But I think you're right to question how much they're even willing to risk in the attempt.

Posted

87 wins?! I guess I didn’t want to believe it. OMG. That makes the Cubs a borderline wild-card team — basically this year’s White Sox (84 wins). Is that really the goal on the North Side? Owww.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
The North Side Baseball Caretaker Fund
The North Side Baseball Caretaker Fund

You all care about this site. The next step is caring for it. We’re asking you to caretake this site so it can remain the premier Cubs community on the internet. Included with caretaking is ad-free browsing of North Side Baseball.

×
×
  • Create New...