The Narrative Importance of Cade Horton's Arrival

[RandallPnkFloyd]

Image courtesy of David Durochik/Diamond Images via Getty Images

Under Jed Hoyer, the Chicago Cubs have been a mixed bag in matters of the draft. 

There have been some successes on both sides of the ball, mostly in the form of guys we think will be impactful in short order (Matt Shaw, Jordan Wicks, Luke Little, James Triantos, Brandon Birdsell). There have been some likely failures, too, where the hope doesn't ring through as strong (Burl Carraway, Ed Howard). Some draftees have been traded away. Others — including some those mentioned on either end of the above spectrum — have seen injuries stall their development. 

There have been some changes in the front office throughout his tenure, but the reality is that the draft hasn't been a source of talent acquisition for the big league level under Hoyer. The team's best work with young names in his time at the helm has come in the form of prospect acquisition via trade (Pete Crow-Armstrong, Ben Brown). Beyond Porter Hodge, we just haven't seen the wire-to-wire type of development that a team aiming for organizational stability would hope to demonstrate. 

Cade Horton can change that. And not just on the development side.

With the confirmed arrival of the team's top pitching prospect this weekend, the current regime has an opportunity for the narrative to flip in their favor. Not only would Horton represent one of the very few that this front office has selected to reach that level, but he possesses the type of upside that even those they've acquired and developed (Brown, Hayden Wesneski, etc.) do not. 

You're talking about frontline starter potential. An upper-90s fastball combined with a wipeout slider combined with decent-enough tertiary offerings. There's likely something of a workload still to be built up, but nothing in his profile is like what the Cubs have featured in recent years. To have a pitcher of this caliber go start-to-finish within the system would be a monumental success for Hoyer & Co., especially when you factor in 2024's health setbacks.

To say nothing of what it would mean in the present for the big league roster. They were already down Justin Steele. Now they're down Shota Imanaga. Ben Brown remains an iffy proposition depending on his command in a given start. The most stability you're getting out of the rotation right now comes from Matthew Boyd, who is outpitching a number of his peripherals. Horton's arrival (and, ideally, his success) would be a morale boost to the pitching staff.

Imanaga's IL placement and the 14-5 loss to San Francisco still linger. They're not healthy. The bullpen — while better than it was at the start of the season — remains at least somewhat unstable. Getting Horton out there against major league hitting with a legitimate chance at sticking around long-term is massive. For Jed Hoyer, and the perception of the front office at large, Horton's debut could signal the health of this organization in the immediate future.

No pressure, though.

View full article