Frank Gore trade?

[rawaction]

I have been offered Stevie Johnson and Santonio Holmes for Frank Gore in a PPR league. We start QB, RB, WR, WR, RB/WR, WR/TE, K, DEF.

 

My lineup would go from:

 

Vick

McCoy

Gore

AJ Green

Marshall

Harvin

 

to

 

Vick

McCoy

S Johnson

Marshall

AJ Green

Holmes

 

Thoughts?

[JimSorgi]

As a former Holmes owner(who traded him as part of a package for Gore), I would not suggest trading for him. His talent will lead to some really good games, but his situation makes him so frustrating. Johnson's good, but I'd much rather have Gore, especially if you can get Hunter as insurance.

[Banedon]

I have both Gore and Holmes. Gore has really started picking it up, while Holmes has dropped off. The Jets are going to Plax a lot more, especially in the endzone. Holmes is my 3rd WR behind Jennings and Steve Smith...so I've gotten by with him. But I really haven't been able to count on him.

[CubmanPi]

Keep Gore.

[rawaction]

I traded Gore and Demaryius Thomas for Dez Bryant and Green-Ellis. Then I traded Green-Ellis, AJ Green, and Ryan Fitzpatrick for MJD and Mike Williams (Tampa).

 

I think I'm ok with it.

 

Vick

McCoy

Jones Drew

Bryant

M Williams

Marshall

[CubmanPi]

Williams will need to have a MUCH better second half for that to sound good to me. Not sure I would have taken that risk.