Would you guys make this trade?

[sporrer17]

I trade Pujols

for Miguel Cabrera and Matt Kemp

 

I'm really torn on this one...I don't really want to get rid of Pujols, but it's a pretty solid offer. I need help in SB, so Kemp would help there, and Miggy is a very solid hitter to replace Pujols.

 

Also, what do you guys think the best plan with Ibanez is...trade him while his value is high? Ride him while he's hot and then move him? Or just stick with him? I personally am kinda leaning towards seeing what I can get for him before he slows down...but I don't want to trade just to trade, either.

[Tracer Bullet]

who is Kemp replacing? That's a pretty good offer, but if you don't have any place to put him or he's not much better than who he's replacing, Kemp probably doesn't justify the trade of Pujols.

 

And I'd see what I could get for Ibanez, again, depending on who you had to replace him.

[sporrer17]

he'd really be sliding into that spot rather than Andy LaRoche, or Ben Francisco, Chris Duncan, Emmanuel Burris, Jarrod Saltalamacchia.

 

But really, he'd be holding a spot until Aramis gets back to take 3b/Util, at which point it'd be between Kemp/Bradley.

 

Here's the rest of my lineup just to give you an idea of where I stand

C Mauer

1b Pujols

2b Kennedy

SS Hardy

3b Figgins

OF Ibanez

OF Dye

OF Scott

UT Bradley

UT Francisco

 

BE Saltalamacchia

BE Burriss

BE An LaRoche

[A-Cal]

um, yeah, do it

[sneakypower]

oh my goodness trade Ibanez yesterday

[sporrer17]

oh my goodness trade Ibanez yesterday

 

The best offer I've gotten for Ibanez is for Mike Cameron straight up. I'm planning on trading him, but I'm not that desperate to move him.