Should I take either of these Fantasy Football trades?

[Anomalied]

I've had the worst luck with running backs this season. I picked Shaun Alexander and Deuce McAllister in the draft, and we all know what happened to Deuce. After he went down, I traded for Cadillac Williams. The first week I have him, he gets hurt and is done for the season, too.

 

I've been starting Derrick Ward, who has been pretty solid but now Jacobs is back so he's not getting as many carries. I currently have the following two offers on the table...

 

Offer 1:

 

I send: TJ Houshmandzadeh

I recieve: Reggie Bush, Calvin Johnson

 

Offer 2:

 

I send: Braylon Edwards

I recieve: Brandon Jacobs, Julius Jones

 

Should I take either?

[Mark_R]

Take both of them.

[WindyCity]

Offer 1 seems like a better deal for you. Julius Jones is garbage. Reggie Bush did well even on a bad offensive day for the Saints and the downgrade from TJ to Calvin Johnson may not be that much -- especially once Chris Henry returns after week 8 and takes away a few targets.

[rawaction]

If your league counts receptions....take offer 1. If not, take offer 1 in a heartbeat and consider offer 2.