AL Cy Young?

[treebird]

 

and that's stupid

 

It's not stupid. I know you want to get into an argument about the true value of W-L, but really, 15-13? Not happening, and even you have to concede that. The mass population would revolt.

 

and that's stupid too.

[DiamondMind]

 

and that's stupid

 

It's not stupid. I know you want to get into an argument about the true value of W-L, but really, 15-13? Not happening, and even you have to concede that. The mass population would revolt.

 

and that's stupid too.

 

so is your face.

[treebird]

 

and that's stupid

 

It's not stupid. I know you want to get into an argument about the true value of W-L, but really, 15-13? Not happening, and even you have to concede that. The mass population would revolt.

 

and that's stupid too.

 

so is your face.

 

takes 1 2 no 1

 

the fact that people would be upset that a guy with a 15-13 record won the cy young really is stupid, though.

[Have a seat, Neifi]

I don't think they should even give pitchers wins and losses. But that ship has obviously sailed.

[treebird]

I don't think they should even give pitchers wins and losses. But that ship has obviously sailed.

 

i say we have a +/- stat for pitchers. look at how many runs their team scores and allows while they are in the game.

 

sound stupid? of course. but it'd be better than wins and losses.

[B]

I need to watch more baseball -- never heard of Carmona before this thread

 

he's a praise and worship singer.

[Mizzou]

There's next to zero chance that a guy with a 15-13 record wins the Cy Young over a guy who is 20-6.

 

and that's stupid

Yeah, I wasn't agreeing I'm just saying it won't happen.

[Ender]

without the injury or caring about W's its Bedard with no doubt in my mind.

 

Since he got hurt and W's seem to matter my money is on Beckett.