Why? LoDuca is a career .285/.339/.417 hitter, which is merely decent for a catcher, he's not that special behind the plate, he's 33, and remember that catchers age early, and he's got $12.5m owed him over the next two years. Well, at least he's a real clubhouse guy. The Mets could have had Ramon Hernandez for not much more than $6.25m a year, though they'd probably have had to go to a third or maybe fourth year. He's 4 years younger, a far superior defensive catcher, and over the last three years he's hit .279/.332/.461, significantly better than Lo Duca, and the Mets would only have had to give up a second round draft pick, which only has the potential of turning into a legitimate prospect. Instead they've given up a legitimate prospect. Gaby Hernandez is just 20, but already has the build of a prototypical power pitcher, at 6 foot 3 and 215 pounds. He's also got two plus pitches already, a great low-nineties sinker with which he's able to miss bats as well as induce groundballs, and a very good curveball with bite. He has fine control of both pitches, and was making strides with a two-seam fastball and particularly with his changeup, which some scouts reckon has the makings of another plus pitch. His numbers... GCL in 2004, 49.2 IP, 25 H, 1 HR, 22 BB, 58 K, 1.09 ERA SS-A in 2004, 3 IP, 2 H, 0 HR, 0 BB, 6 K, 0.00 ERA Low-A in 2005, 92.2 IP, 59 H, 4 HR, 30 BB, 99 K, 2.42 ERA High-A in 2005, 42.1 IP, 48 H, 1 HR, 10 BB, 32 K, 5.74 ERA That's extremely impressive stuff for someone that at the end of the 2005 was just 14 months out of HS. You bring up very good points. Maybe it isn't that great of a deal I though it was.