I'm reluctantly starting to agree. Jacque is solid against RHP, no matter whether people want to admit it or not. 3-8 with 3 doubles in his last two starts. No reason to start Pie at this point. Well, he went 3/8 in his last 2 starts? That's it, you've convinced me - Jacques is great against RHP and should start in CF from now on. All the thought and analysis I put into this question over the first 5 pages didn't take into account his last 8 ABs...and clearly, that's all that matters. You don't have to take an hour and analyze the numbers for everything. Jacque has hit the ball very well in his last two starts. Pie has sucked for a few weeks. If there was a righty starting today, why would you NOT start Jacque? Have you read this thread? b/c I'm not going to retype or cut & paste the posts (mine and others). I'm not going to search through 8 pages to find your reasoning for not wanting to go with the hot hand over the guy who has been awful for several weeks. Well, glad you're part of the discussion. Always nice to have people contribute that can't be bothered to read others' posts. Rather than taking the time to twice tell me that you're not going to re-type your reasoning that you came up with who knows how many posts ago, I imagine that you could've simply stated your reasoning in the same amount of time. But whatever, if it's too bothersome to formulate a response of more than two sentences, then that's your problem.