If anyone is interested in a trip down memory lane, here's the Link to the Topic on NSBB from the trade on July 31, 2012. I started reading around page 124, got to the actual trade announcement on page 130 and read/scanned the next 8-10 pages.
Definitely some interesting (hot) takes, but most seemed at least somewhat pleased with the return. A few things of note:
-Just prior to the trade, the two prospects most coveted were Allen Webster (BOS) and Randall Delgado (ATL).
-Cubs ended up getting Webster a few years later, and while he was a strong prospect before landing with the Cubs, he was pretty much a bust as a big leaguer.
-Webster's MLB WAR is/was -2.4; Delgado's MLB WAR +2.4
-Christian Villanueva was the centerpiece of the trade. Seems like a few people mentioned Mike Olt (who the Cubs also ended up getting eventually) as the better prospect in the Rangers system.
-Not a lot of love for Kyle (and ironically from poster Kyle) if he regularly throws <90 mph; but definite appreciation for his command.
As we are all very aware, Kyle Hendricks was clearly the best MLB AND MiLB player in the trade. And the Cubs clearly came out on top of this deal.
Dempster's MLB WAR 18.6
Webster's MLB WAR -2.4
Delgado's MLB WAR 2.4
Kyle Hendricks MLB WAR 21.3
Thanks Theo!!!!