I don't want to fall because the difference between the second-best player and the third- or fourth-best player is historically pretty significant. If we happen to get a little overslot money out of the deal, that's cool too. Not to mention the possibility that the Astros are dumb again and we get the best player in the draft. I posted this over on PSD first: 1975 to 2000 Overall pick, percentage who posted at least 10 bWAR in MLB, average bWAR per pick. 1, 72%, 31.4 2, 44%, 12.0 3, 36%, 10.2 4, 28%, 9.9 5, 20%, 6.3 27-30, 12%, 3.1 47-50, 10%, 4.7 This isn't the NFL draft where there's a smooth incline of high value all the way through the middle rounds. In the baseball draft, there are a few elite talents and then a pile of undifferentiated mediocrity. The "FIRST-ROUND TALENTS!!!!" that you can get by overslotting later aren't really any better than the 2nd round talents. The small differences among the elite players at the top of the draft are more important than getting an earlier shot at your favorite scratch-off ticket outside the top 10.