While I agree with you, maybe there is a 3rd team that could facilitate this. How about this crazy idea... Cubs Get: Dunn Reds Get: Todd Helton, $2M/year for the rest of his deal from Colorado, Scott Williamson (I love Helton, but the decrease in his HR numbers the past 2 years is somewhat troubling) Rockies Get: Guzman or Hill, Aardsma, Murton, "Top 5" prospect from Reds system The Cubs do this to get the high power, high OBP, high OPS bat they need between a healthy Lee and Aramis. If Dunn has fallen out of favor with the Reds they do this to get Helton who has a better OBP, good glove, and has shown fantastic power in the recent past. They also add a bullpen arm to help them contend this year. The Rockies get a starter to plug into the rotation, a bullpen arm they would control for 4+ years, a starting outfielder, and a good prospect in exchange for a player who really isn't helping them contend at this point. In the offseason the Cubs can then focus on adding one of Zito/Mulder/Schmidt; and improving the bench. 2007 Cubs: C Barrett 1B Lee 2B Walker SS Cedeno 3B Aramis LF Dunn CF Pie RF Jones Zambrano, One of Zito/Mulder/Schmidt, Prior, Marshall, Marmol 6th starter either Hill or Guzman, 7th starter Gallagher or Jerome Williams. If Colorado were playing poorly, that idea may work. Right now the Rockies are in the thick of the NL West race and aren't likely to trade Helton for the package you mentioned. Furthermore, the Rockies are likely going to want statements of faith from Aardsma, Guzman, and Hill. I think Murton has already expressed his Christianity so he should fit in ok.