I'm not against signing Edmonds, but I'm not all that enamored with him either. His injuries concern me. I do prefer him to Pierre, of course I'd prefer a lot of players to Pierre. If Edmonds would sign a 1-year deal, I'd be more inclined to sign him. With Pie in the minors and Pagan on the roster, there is some depth to account for him if he does get injured, which is highly likely. He still was able to post an 831OPS this season which isn't bad from a CF, but he's seen a drop in BA/OBP and especially his SLG. I think he's a better option for hitting second than hitting fifth, but that wouldn't affect whether I'd sign him. If I settled for Edmonds in CF, I'd want some improvement over Theriot at second. If I could get Edmonds on an affordable 1 year 5-6 million deal with an option year around the same amount, I would probably look to sign Durham for 2b. I think this line-up with projected numbers in parenthesis could be productive enough. 2b Durham (285/360/440) CF Edmonds (260/350/480) 1b Lee (290/385/550) 3b Ramirez (289/352/560) RF Jones (280/320/490) LF Murton (295/360/450) C Barrett (285/350/490) SS Izturis (280/300/350)