Why does he have to "greatly" outperform...why isn't it who outperformed? While it is close, Lee had the better season. Pujols may have finished stronger, but his strong finish didn't completely overcome Lee's strong start. Yes, the numbers are close, but when taken altogether, Lee still has the greater numbers. Give the award to the best player, in this case, Derrek Lee. If it's an individual award, the abilities of the players around him shouldn't come into factor.