We'll see if you still feel that way if the game is on the line late and our only pinch hitters left are Hill or Bowen. You haven't thought this through. The alternative is to have one in the lineup for 4 at bats. I give the 4 at bats to Soto and live with the PH risk for one series. I have thought this through. It's better to get rid of one of the catchers and give that space to someone who might actually be useful (Cedeno, Petrick, Murton, Epatt, Kroeger, etc)