Banks-Williams

Counsell and the media like to blame the Cubs losses on the weather, saying the Cubs haven’t had the best hitting conditions. Talk about ridiculous reasoning! Both teams play under the same weather. It is not like it changes from the top of the inning to the bottom. The reason the Cubs are losing is two-fold: (1) they’re leaving men on base, particularly yesterday against the Pirates, and (2) they’re leaving men bullpen is giving up too many runs. Swanson, Bregman, and Busch have not been hitting well. Futher, Jed Hoyer and Carter Hawkins spent too much money on the cheater Bregman, which could have been used to build a bullpen following the losses of Brad Keller and Drew Pomeranz. Riley Martin looks like he’s going to do good things in 2026, but now that Maton and others are on the IL the bullpen is hurting.

Bat speed is mainly important for the long ball. Higher bat speed increases the velocity of the ball towards the fence. Pitch speed also increases velocity of the ball towards the fence. But good contact contributes as well. Amaya has improved contact. That’s why his bat speed is not so important. Amaya has turned into a great hitter because he has improved contact. He is now doing something different from 95% of the hitters. I will not reveal what his secret is to improving contact, but I will tell you this: it is a function of physics and mathematics. Nearly all batters and batting coaches focus on irrelevant things to improve hitting. I focus on the actual science. It is understanding the science that makes hitters great. Amaya — whether he knows the reason or not — is using th key to great hitting. The Cub batters who don’t hit well, like Swanson, Bregman, Busch, and Shaw, all do the opposite of what Amaya does. They too could be great, but they’d have to have the science explained to them and they’d have to choose to implement it.

Mathew Boyd certainly deserves the opening day game. His pitching in 2025 was exceptionally good to say the least. Although he did get battered in game one of the NLDS, that wasn’t his doing. Counsell made the decision to pitch him on only 3 days rest even though he had a fully rested Asad ready to go. A fully-rested Boyd did a vintage performance in the Series on game 4, sending the series to game 5.

Javier Assad is picking up where he left off in the 2025 regular season. He is pitching exceptionally well: https://www.msn.com/en-us/sports/baseball/world-classic-total-domination-javier-assad-delivers-a-masterful-start-in-mexico-vs-great-britain/ar-AA1XGoOu Had Assad got to pitch in the 2025 NLDS, things could have turned out better for the Cubs. Craig Counsell picked Mathew Boyd to pitch game 1 on only 3 days rest even though Assad was pitching better than Boyd at the end of the regular season, and Assad had a full 5 days rest. Milwaukee took advantage of Counsell’s poor decision, battering the Cubbies for 9 runs in the first two innings. Boyd only lasted 0.2 innings; six runs came in. And with men on base Counsell brought in the untested Soroka (he had only pitched 8.1 innings for the Cubs) who gave up 3 earned runs. But for reasons further unknown, Counsell choose not only to not pitch Assad, but he removed him from the roster all together even though Assad was best at keeping men on base from scoring — that is, Assad could have at least been used in relief. Counsell then doubled down on the Boyd-choice mistake by pitching Imanaga in game 2 even though Imanaga was a league leader in giving up home runs. Again the Cubs were pummeled: Imanaga gave up 5 hits — two of them homers —for four earned runs in 2.2 innings. The Cubs, despite a valiant effort, could not recover from the 0-2 deficit. Milwaukee took the NLDS 3-2. Hopefully Assad stays healthy so he can again assist in bringing some October games to Chicago. If he does so and keeps pitching like he’s doing, he’ll no doubt make the October roster in 2026, provided the bats don’t fade in July and August and the bullpen gets rebuilt.

One thing I should also have mentioned here is “lost opportunity cost”. When you put $175M into single person who isn’t really needed because your present guy is doing well — and because he’s young and will likely outperform in the coming years — you don’t have the means to pay for other players who are in fact needed. I just demonstrated that Bregman is not much better, if he is any better at all, than Shaw. Bregman is well behind Shaw in delivering “Effective Doubles”. And in other categories he isn’t much better. He certainly is not a better fielder, perhaps on par now, but even if so, Bregman is aging while Shaw is ripening. So … there was no need to blow $175M on a 3rd baseman. The Cubs needed two things for 2026: (1) a great utility player — a guy who could play most days at most positions to keep the team rested in the hot days of July and August. They didn’t get Castro until ~August 1 last year, after the Cubs began their slide in the summer heat. Counsell was playing his regulars too often. In short, Hoyer and Hawkins made Counsell do a 1969 Durocher. They needed someone like Davey Lopes. Enter Brendan Donovan. They also needed (2) to fill the bullpen. They could have kept Keller but evidently didn’t have the funds. They also could have purchased a couple more reliable guys like Keller. Instead of getting Donovan and three good relievers, they spent $175M on one guy who wasn’t even needed. And they’ve now got Counsell teaching their best defensive 3rd baseman how to play RF That is why I say, if Hoyer and Hawkins were managing my money like that, they’d both be gone. I don’t think the Cubs will win the division this year. They put too much money into ineffectual players like Bregman and Imanaga. Now they’re lacking in relief in the bullpen and, once again, in the field (come July and August). The July and August heat does take its toll on even the best players.

I never said it was the same as a double. That is why is it called an “effective” double. And yes, I have seen a base stealer bring the guy on second and/or third home many times. A base stealer does many beneficial things outside of a true double, like make the pitcher uneasy, which benefits the batter and the base runners. The pitcher is more likely to make a mistake when worrying about the guy on first, thereby allowing a home run or hit off the wall or in the gap. Further, the base stealer has the ability to get the pitcher, the catcher, and the fielders to make errors, enabling the base runners to advance and score in that manner. In other words, base stealers make things happen, and they do create runs. And most importantly, they make the game more exciting for the fans.

Just to show you how poor Hawkins and Hoyer are at their jobs, look at this: Bregman: Cost: $175m/5 = $35,000,000/year 2025 AB = 434, 2B = 28, SB = 1 effective 2B = 2B + SB = 29 Shaw: cost: $760k 2025, pre-arb 2026 2025 AB = 393, 2B = 21, SB = 17 effective 2B = 38; 2B adjusted for more Bregman ABs = 42. If Shaw had as many ABs as Bregman’s, he’d have ~42 effective 2B. That’s 45% more than Bregman in one season. Yet Hoyer and Hawkins pay > 40x more for Bregman, and Bregman is not a better defensive 3rd baseman than Shaw. If I owned the Cubs, both these guys would be relieved in short order.

Quiz time. Name the only baseball manager in ML baseball to dye his hair regularly?

The Red Sox manager, Alex Cora, was one of the cheaters too. As a Houston Coach, he led the cheating pack. Do you think he’d enjoy his present players trashing Bregman? I’m sure no reliable poll was taken.

You are the one who is clueless. Baseball players rarely, if ever, say anything negative about their fellow players. If they did, they’d be traded, released, or sent to the minors. They keep their thoughts to themselves. No doubt, Bregman’s cheating is in everyone’s mind. Nobody respects any of those Houston players.

Just watched the Jed Hoyer interview in the booth with Jim D. and Jon S. Boy is Jed Hoyer clueless. The first questions were about Bregman. Hoyer said Bregman’s reputation and his ability to fit in with the team were his two strong points. I’m not making this up. Go listen to it if you don’t believe me I am sorry Jed, but Bregman has a reputation as a cheater, a guy who participated in the Houston sign stealing scandal for 1-3 years (2017-19). Those years 2017-19, mind you, were Bregman’s best performances. In response to a question about their cheating, former Cub, Cody Bellinger, said: of course they cheated then; why would they stop when they got to the World Series?” Bellinger also accused Altuve of stealing Judges MVP. Bregman does NOT fit in well with the Northsiders. The Cubs have always had a reputation for playing fairly and honestly. Bregman belongs back in Boston with Cora or in Houston with Altuve and Corea.

Hawkins made a huge mistake signing Bregman. He blew out the Cubs’ budget when there was no need to replace Shaw. Did Hawkins not watch the 2025 season games? Shaw did a phenomenal jobs fielding at 3rd. His a gold glover for sure. Hawkins could have got Brendan Donovan — who would have been the perfect fit for the Cubs — but he spent all the Cubs money on a guy who is past his prime and hasn’t had great stats since the cheating years. If Hawkins would have spent just $100k getting Shaw to stop the left foot movement, he’d have gotten a young all-star for a fraction of the Bregman dollars and could have had Donovan and a great reliever like Keller to boot. Frankly I have no idea why Hawkins has that job.

Tauchman’s OBP is better than Bregman’s over the past two years, and Hawkins paid $35M/year for him for 5 years. They could easily get Tauchman for a small fraction of Bregman’s pay. Plus, Tauchman is a very good fielder and is loved by fellow Cub players and the fans. Of course the same can’t be said for Bregman since he was involved in the cheating scandal in 2017-19, which took ALCS and World Series and MVPs (and thus salaries) from other more deserving players.

The Cubs didn’t have Willi Castro until too late in the 2025 season. The net result was tired ball players in the July and August sun. Counsell played the regulars each game, causing a slump just when the Brewers got hot. By the time the weather cooled and Castro came in to assist, it was too late; the damage had been done. The Cubs thus ended up in the wild card round, and Counsell doubled down on his mistakes, pitching Boyd on only 3 days rest instead of Assad on 5 days rest against the Brewers. Assad had demonstrated better pitching than Boyd at the end of the season, but Counsell didn”t notice: he took Assad off the roster! The Cubs lost game one — Boyd was destroyed in the early innings. Counsell then went double or nothing yet again, tripling down on his mistakes: he pitched Imanaga as the starter in game 2 even though Imanaga was a league leader in giving up home runs and doubles. He kept the trend going. The Cubs got clobbered yet again and couldn’t recover. Season was over. Counsell did a 1969 Durocher. Lesson learned?? Rotate your players in July and August, and keep your eye out for tired ones throughout the season. Do not spend time worrying about your hair color or giving media interviews. Watch your players closely Mr. Counsell. And get someone like Brendan Donovan on the roster now that Castro is gone

My point is that when you hire a thief like Bregman, it curtails your options. Turner and Bellinger were no longer options to hire because they are the victims of Bregman et al.’s theft. There are many other players who were hurt by the 2017 to 2019 games against Houston, particularly those on the Dodgers and Yankees. I particularly would have liked to have seen Bellinger return to Chicago since Tucker went elsewhere. There are also players who would not have wanted Bregman on their team, particularly star players who rip off their fellow MLB players. I don’t think Horrner, Swanson, PCA, Happ, or Suzuki are happy he came aboard. Hoyer and Counsell didn’t seem to think this one through. Cora didn’t care cause he was the leader of the cheaters. Bregman should have stayed in Boston or returned to Houston like fellow cheater Corea.

Cubs need someone like Brendan Donovan. They lost their utility man Willi Castro to the Rockies for $12 million. The Cubs team needs a versatile player who can enable full time rotations in the infield and outfield. Otherwise Mr. Counsell will ruin his regulars in the July and August heat like he did in 2025.

Dude — you really need to learn some reading comprehension. I never said what you claim I said. Not even close. And it is impossible for you to know my emotions. So your little post is what is complete nonsense.

Well … the Cubs could sign Justin Turner for another season. He would not cost much, and he can sit in for Busch against lefties. Turner did bat 276 against them with a 769 OPS to boot. And he did come through in the clutch with a couple of walk offs. He’s the kind of guy young players like PCA enjoy talking to in the dugout and after work. His fielding was good too. But “Houston, we have a problem” with. bringing Turner back into the fold now. The newly signed third baseman, who played with Houston in 2017, seemingly stole Turner’s World Series ring from him. Turner stood in the dirt by 3rd base in his Dodgers’ uniform when Bregman was batting with foreknowledge of the oncoming Dodger pitches. Houston was breaking the rules with their sophisticated sign stealing system. Although Turner was the NLCS co-MVP, he wasn’t going to earn such in the World Series since Houston took it in 4 games, all won in Houston. Having Bregman occupying the dugout and clubhouse with Turner around probably would be awkward to say the least. Same would go for bringing Bellinger back to the Northside, particularly since Bellinger has been outspoken about the theft. Both Bellinger and Turner were starters for the Dodgers in the 2017 World Series. If either of these two gentlemen were to wear the Cubs uniform in 2026, perhaps Bregman could make amends by issuing a public apology and by giving them his WS ring. Well … I guess he could do so in any case. But he seems like the kind of guy who wants to pretend it didn’t happen so everyone will forget.

Counsell needs to keep alternating catchers throughout the regular season. He didn’t do much that with the infielders and outfielders in 2025 until September. It cost the Cubs. He also could have given Kelly a break during the post season. He played him everyday. It is easy for Counsell to sit in the dugout shade and give orders, but playing in the field and having to bat against 96 mph pitchers is another story Like Leo Durocher in ‘69, the Cubs faded from first place in the July and August sun. Playing your regulars everyday in the summer heat has its influence. Hopefully Castro and Shaw will be used regularly to keep players refreshed. It also would be nice to see Shaw starting at 3rd instead of the cheater Bregman. Bregman is better suited playing ball in Houston or with his cheating manager Alex Cora in Boston. He doesn’t fit in well in Wrigleyville. It is too nice of a place for guys like him.

You don’t get baseball stats or scientific method. Bregman was worse in his prime years age 26-30 than in his cheating years age 23-25. You’d expect him to hit better during those years, yet he does the opposite. True pitchers have gotten better, but that didn’t happen in one year, 2019 to ‘20. You try to compare home to road games. Assuming the data you have is correct, it is only anecdotal because it is influenced by events. He is facing the same teams, that is, the same pitchers and catchers. He knows how the pitchers and catchers think. He’s seen the pitch series before. He knows how they like to set the batters up — so he will hit better on the road too. And that brings his overall numbers up. The road/home numbers could just be randomness; they could be the result of trouble at home with the wife, newborn babies who keep him up, friends who call, drinking alcohol at home with company, etc etc. You just don’t know. But if you compare the years, like I did, all these factors cancel themselves out. A yearly comparison thus is far more controlled. The road/home comparison is scientifically flawed. Okay — so that’s it for me. I’m not going to teach you science further.

I have already talked about his hitting post cheating on this forum many times. Go look at his stats yourself! There nothing to write home about. He bats a little above average, he rarely steals a base, he usually strikes out more than he walks (he only had more BB than SO in two years post cheating), and he only hit 18 HRs last year. He’s no superstar. His great years were 2017-19. Any wonder? Don’t ridicule something you haven’t watched.

Dear Matt: You cite Bergman’s leadership and his patience in the batter’s box as being good reasons for the Cubs paying so much for his employment. Let’s look at the batter’s box first. If what you say is correct, he’s only hitting 25% above the league average with plenty of rest (only 114 games). There’s no reason Shaw can’t do that with an adjustment to his unnecessary body movements. And Shaw surely is a better fielder. Bregman isn’t going to be anywhere as good in the hot seat as he ages. And his batting is not likely to improve. His best years, which are the ones that gave him notoriety, are the ones where his team was accused of having foreknowledge of the pitches. You don’t pay an extreme salary for someone who is batting a little above average and who is getting up there in age. Thus as things presently stand, 2026 would be a toss up between Bregman and Shaw. With respect to leadership, you can’t ask that from a guy who cheated. His batting averages and home run counts during the accused cheating years are much better than those is his prime years which followed. I don’t think the younger guys want advice from someone who cheated his way up the ladder. Bad mojo, Hoyer made a big boo-boo bringing this guy to the Northside. He’s not the guy you’d be thinking about when you’re singing Go Cubs Go, It is too happy a song, and not written for cheaters like Bregman.

Why would they stop after 2017? The cheating wasnt revealed until late 2019. Go on YouTube and watch the videos some sleuths put together sbout 2018-19. Altuve’s 2019 game 6 ALCS walk-off homer is highly questionable. Ken Rosenthal was bery suspicious and questioned him about why he prevented his teammates from removing his shirt. Arrolis Chapman, the pitcher, believed he was cheating as well. The necklace beneath his shirt is believed to have contained a signaling device. Altuve gave some very strange answers when questioned about the fear of shirt removal (he’d removed it a few times before). Go watch the videos, and you’ll be convinced they were cheating in 2019 up to at least the end of the ALCS.

I don’t trust the MLB. I don’t even like it. They didn’t even take away the 2017 World Series title from Houston. Why not? They let a team keep their victory even though they had foreknowledge of all the pitches! WTF!? Makes you wonder if the execs placed bets on Houston (with inside information perhaps) and were afraid they’d have to give the $$ back. As far your claim that he batted better on the road than at home, I highly doubt that is true. I also highly doubt you have personal knowledge of such; thus, what you state is merely heresay. If you go on youtube, you can find many videos pointing out evidence of Houston cheating in 2019 — things like batters moving forward in the batters box and then getting a change-up that they hit over the wall. Arolis Chapman believes Altuve cheated in game 6 of the 2019 ALCS when he hit his game 6 walk off. Suspicious Ken Rosenthal asked him why he was telling his team mates to not remove his shirt after the hit. First he said he was shy, then he said his wife told him not to, then he said he has a bad tattoo. You can see him wearing something around his neck, which some say was a signaling device. All very odd — so do not tell me that you know they quit in 2018. Stole the ALCS from the Yankees twice if true. After seeing Altuve’s behavior, I agree with Chapman.