To be honest, I can see both sides here. If Prior were to sign a contract with a relatively cheap buyout of his 1st year of FA, he might be shooting himself in the foot. He watched us give Jason Marquis a big contract after putting up a 6+ ERA. He's got to think if he can come back by mid year and do well he can get a lot better. At the same time, I understand why the Cubs are hesitant to put more money into him without the security of the option. In the end, though, I feel that we should tender him a contract and go to arbitration if need be. I have zero faith that the 3 mil or so would be spent any better than on the Prior Lotto, and I also have zero belief that 3 million would really stop us from doing anything else. Sign him, ride him hard to get back as early as possible, and see where things go. Maybe he comes back and has a great time and we can mend this. Maybe not.