according to fangraps, fielder has been worth 3.5 more total war in 4 less seasons. he's far younger and he's far better, your logic is [expletive] Looking at average WARs is a helluva lot more logical than looking at total WAR. i don't see why, as part of the reason for mentioning total war was due to the fact that fielder has 4 less years of service than pena, and has been worth a significant amount more. he's also younger and a permanent solution at first at the age of 27. over the last 3 years, fielder has been worth 5.1 WAR per year, Pena has been worth 2.1. for those that can't count, that's 3 wins per year, a significant amount considering that's two and a half times more.